I’ve written about this before, in my post Are Your Cleaning Products Toxic?, but my experience this past week inspired me to write about it again. So many household and cleaning products seem to be scented these days — you can’t go to the store to buy something as basic as garbage bags without them being “scented”.
Ironically, as more and more people are developing health issues ranging from sensitivities to chemicals, to cancer from contact with unknown environmental toxins, corporations like Proctor & Gamble, and Krogers are scenting everything imaginable. Many fragrances and scents contain carcinogenic or toxic chemicals. Do you use scented household products? Are your scented household products toxic? And how would you know if they were?
Last week I decided to do a major spring-clean of my office. My office building is in a light-industrial area next to a cement truck facility, which makes my office very dusty. While I normally clean my boat using a rag and Solumel (a tea tree oil based cleaner made by Melaluca), I find Swiffers to be a more efficient way to clean my office because they are statically charged to attract dust, and the woven fabric holds the dust better than a rag. So my husband Kirk picked up a box of Swiffers for me when he was at the store, and dropped them off at my office.
When he handed me the box of Swiffers, I immediately smelled a strong scent, and noticed that the box said “Fabreeze scent”. I didn’t realize that Swiffers even came “scented”, and remarked on it. Kirk was surprised that he hadn’t noticed it himself, and he asked if I wanted him to return them. Not wanting to waste his time, and wanting to get cleaning my office I decided to go ahead and use them this one time.
Within a minute or two, the palm of my hand was stinging (I use the Swiffers as a dust cloths, not with one of their intended gadgets so I was holding it in my hand.) I washed my hands, and then used a paper-towel to hold onto the Swiffer, to finish up cleaning my dusty office. I threw away the rest of the box of Swiffers and emptied the garbage, which was already starting to stink up my whole office. I left my window wide open all night, and went home.
The next morning when I came into work, I was hit by an over-powering smell of “Fabreeze”. I left my door and window open all day to get a cross ventilation, but several hours after being there, my eyes were stinging, my throat was burning, and I had a headache, which I never get. WHAT is in that “Fabreeze” anyway? I decided to look up the ingredients on P&G’s website.
Shockingly, they won’t tell you exactly which chemicals are in their products—their list of ingredients for all products is “proprietary”, but they offer a 16 page PDF in a 2-column list, filled with long-named chemical ingredients that I can’t pronounce. Turns out they have over 40 household products that contain “Fabreeze” scent, including air fresheners, and fabric softeners. I hate to think what those chemicals would do to your lungs and skin if you use those products.
Are Your Scented Household Products Toxic?
I decided to do some more research and found Environmental Working Group’s (EWG) website where they have a guide to healthy cleaning products. EWG* independently tests a wide range of products from personal health and beauty products to household cleaning products. They test for toxic chemicals, carcinogens, chemicals that cause nerve damage, and birth defects, among other things. Are your scented household products toxic? You can look up the products you use on the EWG website. I was not at all surprised to find that of the “Fabreeze” products they tested:
- 2 products rated a “C” (MODERATE CONCERN: Some potential for hazards to health or the environment)
- 24 products scored a “D” (HIGH CONCERN: Likely hazards to health or the environment, poor ingredient disclosure)
- 14 products scored an “F” (HIGHEST CONCERN Potentially significant hazards to health or the environment and poor ingredient disclosure)
Though I don’t normally buy chemically scented products, it was a lesson to us to be much more diligent in reading labels, and checking for scents in any household product that we purchase. We try to buy our household products from our local PCC Natural Market, which does an excellent job of vetting products for toxins.
Better yet, you can make your own cleaners from white vinegar, baking soda, lemons, and other ingredients you have on hand at home. Try these DYI home cleaning remedies from Real Simple.
*EWG provides information on cleaning product ingredients from the published scientific literature, to supplement incomplete data available from companies and the government. The ratings indicate the relative level of concern posed by exposure to the ingredients in this product – not the product itself – compared to other product formulations. The ratings reflect potential health hazards but do not account for the level of exposure or individual susceptibility, factors which determine actual health risks, if any.